How we test and choose
What a pick has to earn
Every category has three picks: a Good one that does the job for the least money, a Better one most people should buy, and a Best one for when budget isn't the deciding factor. A product only earns a spot if it does what it claims, works with the ecosystems we say it works with, and doesn't hide a required subscription.
How we judge
- Compatibility: which of Apple Home, Google Home, Alexa, SmartThings and Home Assistant it works with, and whether it supports Matter, Thread, Zigbee or Z-Wave.
- Setup: whether a renter can install it without drilling, and whether it needs a hub or a professional.
- Ongoing cost: whether core features need a subscription.
- Reliability and support: firmware update history, recalls, and how long the manufacturer has supported earlier models.
- Value: what you get, and what you give up, at each price.
Hands-on testing and research
Some picks are based on hands-on use in a real home; others are based on research: specifications, manufacturer documentation, independent testing and owner reports. Each review says which it is. We never describe a product as tested if we haven't used it.
Keeping picks current
Prices, availability and recalls are re-checked automatically. When something changes enough to affect a pick, the page is updated and its "updated" date changes.
What money can't buy
Brands cannot pay for a place on our lists. We earn a commission when you buy through some of our links (see our affiliate disclosure), and that never decides which product we pick.